Bring back the command line, all is forgiven... - The Test Bed

The Test Bed, the latest news on all the hottest products passing through the PCW Labs

Personal Computer World

« Passport to a rip-off? | Main | Free remote control »

Bring back the command line, all is forgiven...

The advent of graphical interfaces such as Windows and the MacOS was rightly hailed as an advance in usability, but as anyone who ever used Unix or pre-Windows DOS will know they could make some tasks more cumbersome and less natural to perform. You could, for instance, tell DOS with a single command to list to a file all filenames in a particular folder containing the letters xkz; try doing that in Windows.

One of the least-appreciated aspects of speech-recognition programs is that they have brought back the command-line in a new form. Instead of writing near-English commands, with obscure and daunting modifiers, you can tell your program verbally what to do - which is far more natural than clicking a mouse.

They show that commands can make things easier even for that majority of people who would run a mile at being asked to cope with anything that looks like a line of code. Take, for instance, the task of setting up four-column-by--row table in Word 2003. First you need to know the difference between Draw Table and Insert on the menu; then you have to complete a dialogue box. With a spoken command you need to know nothing about the menu structure; you just say something likeInsert 10 by 4 table.

Natural-language processing has come a long way since DOS days so it should be possible for commands to be closer to the way we speak. There are problems, such as possible security breaches or data loss stemming from ambiquities. Firefox is making a start with its about-to-launch Ubiquity command interface. It looks like a project well worth watching. 

Comments

Having played with ubiquity a bit since its launch I am impressed, but it needs a bit of improvement in the speed department for complex sites. It's definitely a step forward though - point & click is not our natural way of thinking.

Posted by Chris at LG | September 2, 2008 12:40 PM

Post a comment







Type the characters you see in the picture above.


Site credentials: About | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Top of the page
© Incisive Media Investments Limited 2010, Published by Incisive Financial Publishing Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, are companies registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 04252091 & 04252093