« Keep Wifi at the edge - and be wary of channel aggregation | Main | Nintendo DS becomes an ebook reader »
Humax Foxsat HDR - a first look
The Humax Foxsat HDR is one of the first Freesat+ devices, and we'll be publishing a review in the March issue of PCW, when we've finished our testing. Meanwhile, we're going to share some of the inside information, and our first impressions of the device.
First, if you're not sure what Freesat's all about, read this introduction. Freesat+ is the brand name that's being used for PVRs on the platform, which allows you to record and play back, without a subscription, including the HD content that's broadcast, though admittedly that's fairly limited at the moment.
The Humax box is a sleek piece of kit, with a front panel that sports just a power switch and an LCD display; round the back you'll find optical audio output, HDMI and SCART sockets, ethernet - for future use, including a version of the BBC iPlayer - and a USB port. The front panel drops down to reveal another USB port, and a few extra buttons to allow you to navigate the menus or change channel without the remote.
The remote itself is a fairly large affair, which can also control other devices; it works ok, though we've found it to be fairly directional - in our test rig, the HDR is at the side of the room, and we need to point the remote at it for reliable results.
Installation is pretty straightforward - like any twin tuner satellite box, you'll usually need two connections from your dish; we'll have more on that later. A wizard detects your satellite LNB, asks for your postcode, and sets the regional versions of some channels for you; if you're in Scotland or Ireland, you might want to pick an English postcode so that you get ITV HD, though.
Picture quality looks pretty good, for both HD and SD channels, connected via HDMI to our display, though it's worth noting that we didn't get a picture when using our HDMI switch box, something we'll investigate further.
Some interface issues
When you call up the EPG, the picture disappears briefly as the box fetches the data from the Freesat EPG transponder, but then it reappears behind the guide; there's no annoying music, as found on Sky's kit. Recording is a simple matter of highlighting a programme in the guide and pressing the Rec button on the remote - but if you do, you won't be asked if you want to record a series. For that, you need to press OK, choose if you want to watch or record the program, then press OK, choose SD or HD if both are available, and then on the next press of OK you'll be asked if you want to record the whole series. We'd like an option to do all that in one press, frankly.
Some other bits of the interface need a few too many presses, like deleting files, for example. And there's still the bonkers Freesat genre screen that forces an extra press to get into the EPG, though Humax has wisely provided an option to turn that off.
Overall, our first impressions are of a pretty good box, good picture quality, and easy to get to grips with, though with some niggles; we'll be doing more testing over the next week or so, before our full review.
Under the hood
Meanwhile, a little bit about the technical aspects; the HDR is powered by a Broadcom 7403 chip; it's one of the first to use this brand new system-on-a-chip - the earlier Humax iCord uses the 7401. The use of such a new part helps explain the £300 price tag - but it should ensure it's going to keep up with developments on Freesat.
It also supports Single Cable Distribution (SCD), otherwise known as Unicable. Right now, we're testing with a Unicable LNB from Inverto. This allows up to four compatible receivers to be connected using a single cable, rather than requiring one cable per tuner. A normal LNB shifts the satellite signals to an intermediate frequency; with Unicable, there can be up to four of those intermediate frequencies, and each tuner is assigned one, which it uses to talk to the LNB, which contains four independent LNB units and the electronics to handle the signalling between them and the receivers. So if you don't want to run extra cables Unicable could be a solution - as long as all your kit's compatible, and you don't mind paying around £70 for the LNB - we got ours from Germany, including shipping. Buy in the UK and pay around £80.
However, we're still testing this aspect of the HDR, and we'll report more on that via the blog; it's also not a configuration that appears to be detected by the install wizard; instead you have to access a hidden menu to enable it, so probably not one for the casual user just yet.
PS. Don't forget that one of the prizes in the competition for the January 2009 issue of PCW is a Foxsat HDR, courtesy of Turbosat. If you're reading this before the 24th of December 2008, why not head along to the competition page and see if you can win?
Unicable Update, 16th December
After a little more playing around - the full review of the HDR will appear in the March 2009 issue, out next month - it's time for some more comments on the Unicable side of things, which is one of the more interesting technical aspects of the Humax.
Unfortunately, we have to report that we didn't have a lot of success; while the box proved quite stable when testing with a standard dual-LNB and twin cable setup, we had many more problems with the Unicable. This included poor performance, problems with dual recording, and complete lock-ups requiring a power off to recover. Now, this could be a problem with the LNB - we only had one available to test - but our gut feeling is that the Unicable support in the box isn't fully working.
Perhaps that shouldn't be a massive surprise, as it's not a mode of operation that the standard setup procedure will even allow, but it will be disappointing to anyone who wants to avoid running extra cables. Humax tells us that they may revisit this area of the firmware in future.
If you've tried Unicable, please let us know; it is, unfortunately, a bit fiddly; as well as having to access a hidden menu to activate it on the HDR, most satellite finders - especially cheap ones - don't support Unicable LNBs either, so you need to line up the dish with a standard one, and make sure there's no accidental movement when you swap LNBs.
It's also worth pointing out that one frustrating aspect of the Humax in this regard is that the diagnostic screen makes it very hard to check that you have a good signal on both tuners. Although it shows the tuned transponder on each tuner, with strength and quality, it shows the same one for both. You can't access the menu while recording, so you can't force each one onto a different channel and then check, which would have been helpful in trying to troubleshoot our Unicable setup.
So, a regretful thumbs down for Unicable support at the moment - but do remember that that's just one part of the HDR, and not something that the vast majority of users will have any issues with.



Really useful, esp info about cable distribution.
Posted by Richard | November 30, 2008 9:31 AM
Don't agree with too many presses do delete. I've had a Humax Freeview PVR for 3 years now and never deleted a file I didn't want. Can't say that about my PC though!
Posted by Tony M | November 30, 2008 6:45 PM
I agree with the comments regarding the remote and I need to be near and directly infront of the HDR for any response. Would like to see a software update to improve the perfomance of the remote.
Posted by Steve Surrey | December 29, 2008 3:53 PM
I have used the new Foxsat HDR now for three weeks. It often 'hangs' for no reason that I can see. It then has to be disconnected from the mains electricity supply before it operates again. It is often slow to react to a key press on the remote. Other time it reacts instantly. Picture is good and generally it seems to be a good box.
Posted by Derek | January 1, 2009 9:12 PM
the remote control issue is because of the limited aperture on the front cover of the humax. If you flip down the front cover then you get a much wider range of IR coverage.
Posted by jason | January 5, 2009 6:36 AM
Regarding the Unicable installation...the Inverto Unicable LNB has two ports - one of which is legacy (acting as a common standard universal Single LNB) so when you install Unicable you use the Legacy port in order to tune your dish (surely you can use any SatFinder with that legacy port if you have one) and once done you simple move the RF cable to the unicable port with no risk that the dish will move.
Posted by One that knows | January 15, 2009 12:40 PM
Not all Unicable LNBs have a legacy port - only certain of the Inverto models have one. So yes, if you do decide to spend the extra on one with the legacy port, you'll be able to use an existing satellite finder.
However, when we were hunting around for a Unicable LNB to use in our testing, we didn't find any sellers offering the models with the legacy port.
Hopefully, as Unicable becomes more popular, it'll be easier to find the whole range of LNBs, at more sensible prices too.
Posted by Nigel Whitfield | January 15, 2009 2:26 PM
there appears to be very indifferent technical support
for the foxsat hdr either via email or phone which is particularly frustrating because of a lack of precise information in the manuel
Posted by mjs | January 30, 2009 5:41 PM
Does anyone know why we are unable to delete video files - the red delete button is greyed out.
Posted by Mary Hawker | May 10, 2009 9:31 PM
You cannot delete files on the HDR while a recording is in progress
Posted by Nigel Whitfield | May 11, 2009 11:27 AM
I received this disappointing e.mail from Humax this morning
“You cannot use the uni cable as this will not make any difference to how many feeds are in the unit, you will need 2 LNB cables going into the unit and then this will enable you to record two channels at the same time”.
Kind regards,
Humax Customer Support
Any thoughts?
Chris
Posted by Chris Howling | November 10, 2009 11:24 AM
This means one of two things.
Either the customer support rep doesn't understand what Unicable actually is for (replacing two cables with one, that still provides two feeds), which I'd rate as quite high, given how little it's used in this country.
Or, secondly, they've decided to quietly drop support for Unicable, since it was pretty flaky in the first case.
Posted by Nigel Whitfield | November 10, 2009 11:40 AM